Paying for a random pull is paying for a chance. Most pulls are worth less than the pack, and any “expected value” a platform shows is measured against its own card prices, while selling back usually pays less than that. Decide your limit before you open anything. Free, confidential help: 1-800-GAMBLER (US) · GamCare 0808 8020 133 (UK).
CSDB · Pack opening sites
Arena Club vs Courtyard
Both sell packs of real graded cards that stay in a vault until you ship them. The difference that matters most is the sell-back: Arena Club publishes a fixed 90% offer, while Courtyard’s Instant Sale is a per-product percentage its terms call best-effort and time-limited. Courtyard covers far more categories, from watches to comics.
No affiliate links. CSDB has no commercial deal with any platform on this page and no promo codes to give you. Links go straight to each official site.
Side by side
| Arena Club | Courtyard | |
|---|---|---|
| Operator | ArenaClub.com, Inc. Founder and CEO Brian Lee; founding partner Derek Jeter. | Courtyard, Inc., 228 Park Ave S #38294, New York, NY 10003 |
| What you can open | Graded cards: Football, Pokémon, One Piece, Basketball, Soccer, Baseball, Hockey | Pokémon, One Piece, Baseball, Basketball, Football, Watches, Sneakers, Comics (CGC 9.8+), Graded Coins |
| Pack prices | Seen on 21 Nov 2026: $50, $75, $500, $600, $1,000 | Seen on 21 Nov 2026: $15 to $5,000 |
| Selling back | Arena Club Offer at 90% of estimated value ($72 on an $80 card). Slab Safe (+10%) guarantees at least 80% of pack price or 90% of value. | Instant Sale at a percentage of fair market value shown on the product page; best-effort, time-limited; FMV set by a proprietary algorithm. |
| Getting the card | Vault near Portland, Oregon. Retrieval $1 per card plus shipping and insurance; 2-day above $1,000. FedEx/UPS (US), FedEx/DHL (international); recipient pays duties. | Vault in Delaware; FedEx; ships to most countries. |
| Odds and fairness | Card values come from comps of recent sales. Coin Cases, Wine Drops and Time Boxes list odds. | No per-card odds table found on the pack page we read. Sneaker packs state "fully disclosed distribution odds". |
| Who can use it | Age of majority and 18+, using your own card. | 18+. |
| Trustpilot | 1.6 from 45 reviews | 3.7 from 1,078 reviews |
Fees
Arena Club publishes them all: 10% for marketplace sellers; buyers pay 0% from the wallet, 0.8% by ACH (max $5) or 2.9% + $0.30 by card; retrieval is $1 per card plus shipping and insurance. We did not find an equivalent fee table on Courtyard’s pages.
Full write-ups: Is Arena Club legit? · Is Courtyard.io legit?
Questions
- Which pays more when you sell back, Arena Club or Courtyard?
- Arena Club publishes a fixed rate: its Arena Club Offer is 90% of a card's estimated value. Courtyard's Instant Sale is a percentage of fair market value shown on each product page, and its terms call it best-effort and time-limited.
- Are Arena Club and Courtyard both NFT sites?
- Courtyard tracks each vaulted item as an NFT and takes USDC on Polygon. Arena Club sells Slab Packs of graded cards held in its vault and takes wallet, ACH or card payments.
- Where are the vaults?
- Arena Club's is near Portland, Oregon. Courtyard's is in Delaware.
Where this comes from
- Arena Club help centre
- Arena Club Slab Packs
- Arena Club about us
- Trustpilot: arenaclub.com
- Courtyard terms of service
- Courtyard help centre
- Courtyard vending machine
- Pokémon Inferno pack page
- Trustpilot: courtyard.io
All platforms: pack opening sites compared.